Ep 21 - Rabbis Jodi Kornfeld and Adam Chalom - Say What You Believe: Humanistic Judaism and an Atheist Rabbi

Episode 21 • November 21, 2026 • 01:35:39
Ep 21 - Rabbis Jodi Kornfeld and Adam Chalom - Say What You Believe: Humanistic Judaism and an Atheist Rabbi
Bad At My Religion
Ep 21 - Rabbis Jodi Kornfeld and Adam Chalom - Say What You Believe: Humanistic Judaism and an Atheist Rabbi

Nov 21 2026 | 01:35:39

/

Hosted By

Josh Galt

Show Notes

Rabbi Jodi Kornfeld and Rabbi Adam Chalom are Humanistic Jews. Jodi founded Beth Chaverim Humanistic Jewish Community near Chicago, and Adam is the rabbi of Kol Hadash Humanistic Congregation and Dean of the International Institute for Secular Humanistic Judaism. Together they edited Contemporary Humanistic Judaism: Beliefs, Values, Practices. Their movement keeps Jewish culture, holidays, and community, and leaves out any prayer its members don't believe.

Josh comes at it as a seeker who does believe in something divine. He asks where ethics come from with no God watching, whether a people defined by ancestry can call itself humanist, whether they believe in God at all, and what happens to a tradition once you start changing its words. Jodi answers that she is a rabbi and an atheist. Adam would rather be known by what he does believe.

Where they land is integrity: say what you mean, mean what you say, and don't pretend. They changed one word of an old prayer, from "He will make peace" to "we will make peace." Josh describes standing through Mass beside his Catholic wife, and the three of them agree on the difference between respect and pretending. They also talk about AI as the golem, forgiveness without God on Yom Kippur, and teaching children to ask why.

Correction: the "bless me" story Josh retells at 1:07:33 is from Father Augustine Wetta (Ep 13), who is a Benedictine monk, not a Franciscan.

About Jodi Kornfeld and Adam Chalom: Rabbi Jodi Kornfeld founded Beth Chaverim Humanistic Jewish Community in the northern suburbs of Chicago in 2003 and is its rabbi. She was ordained by the International Institute for Secular Humanistic Judaism in 2009, holds a Doctor of Science in Jewish Studies from Spertus Institute, and is president of the Association of Humanistic Rabbis. Rabbi Adam Chalom, PhD, is Dean of the International Institute for Secular Humanistic Judaism and rabbi of Kol Hadash Humanistic Congregation in suburban Chicago. Together they edited Contemporary Humanistic Judaism: Beliefs, Values, Practices (The Jewish Publication Society, 2025).

Contemporary Humanistic Judaism (the book): https://jps.org/books/contemporary-humanistic-judaism/
Beth Chaverim Humanistic Jewish Community: https://www.bethchaverim.net/
Kol Hadash Humanistic Congregation: https://www.kolhadash.com
International Institute for Secular Humanistic Judaism: https://www.iishj.org
Society for Humanistic Judaism: https://shj.org

Chapters:
0:00 Intro
1:01 What Humanistic Judaism is
1:52 Jewish history without a commanding God
6:04 Humanism for one people: the piccolo in the orchestra
9:13 Ethics with no one watching
12:31 Can people carry that responsibility?
16:51 Tribalism and rooted cosmopolitans
21:43 Do you believe in God? Who counts as Jewish
27:55 Integrity: "we will make peace"
29:38 Pushback from Orthodox Judaism
33:21 What a Humanistic rabbi does
37:14 Kippah, tallit, and Shabbat as a choice
42:20 AI and the golem
46:33 Would robots get rights?
52:55 Changing a tradition from inside it
56:51 Religion, culture, and peoplehood
59:45 Amen, blessed, and standing without kneeling
1:07:23 "Bless me": forgiveness and Yom Kippur
1:13:55 Why words matter
1:19:12 Cognitive dissonance, and being Jewish by proxy
1:25:03 Teaching kids to ask why
1:30:53 Thirty days: what to try
1:34:01 The book, and where to find them

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:02] Speaker A: Today's guests are Rabbi Jodi Kornfeld and Rabbi Adam Shalom. [00:00:08] Speaker B: So I personally do not believe in God. And I, you know, when I teach my Sunday school kids, if they're going to ask me that question directly, I answer them directly. I don't try and hedge. I have kids and families, some of whom will say, I don't believe in God either. And I think they feel supported in being able to say that. And then I have other ones who say, you know, I do believe in God. And my answer is, well, that's. I'm happy for you that you are reaching your own conclusions. You know, so I can be a humanistic Jew and a rabbi and an atheist and not impose my own viewpoint so much as expose my viewpoint and let people learn, kids especially, learn to be critical thinkers. [00:00:56] Speaker C: You're listening to the bad at my religion podcast, hosted by Josh God. [00:01:01] Speaker B: So humanistic Judaism takes Jewish culture and centers it to be the basis of Jewish identity. It has two components, as its name suggests, humanistic, or the philosophy of humanism, the belief in the power and authority of human beings over their own lives. And Judaism, which we define very broadly and as the collective historic experience of the Jewish people. And so that will, of course, include religion, but it's so much more than religion. So it involves every aspect of Jewish culture, Jewish art, Jewish music, Jewish languages, Jewish foods. Everywhere that Jews have lived, they have lived experiences that they have lived Jewishly, and they have brought that experience to that collective historic experience. [00:01:51] Speaker D: Okay, and maybe to enlighten me a little bit more on this topic, because there's so much information out there that even reading to try and get different perspectives on the history of the Jewish people. How does a humanist sort of view that. That takes a. I guess I would call it a secular view of the Jewish people. How does that work with the history? Because in my understanding of the Jewish people, it's always been religious centered or driven or with, well, the law, the Torah, but some sort of deity figure involved. And maybe I'm misunderstanding that. So could you speak to that a little bit? [00:02:40] Speaker E: Well, one of the complexities of Jewish history is, is that you've had the Jewish people for a long time, but what they believe has changed radically over the centuries. There were many centuries where Jews worshiped multiple gods, even attested in the Hebrew Bible when in the Book of Kings, they're cleaning out the temple of all these other idols and statues that were there. But they were there for hundreds of years, and that was what Judaism was. And then for a long time it was one God, but it was a temple in Jerusalem with animal sacrifices, as detailed in, in the Hebrew Bible, both the historical books and in the Torah's rules of what to do. But if you go to a Jewish temple today, there's no altar, there's no blood, there's no animals. It's changed tremendously to a system of prayer and commandments rather than animal sacrifices and a priesthood where the heredity matters and they're in charge of everything. So the shift from priestly to rabbinic Judaism was a major change over the centuries. You had Jews that were more philosophically inclined and some Jews were more mystically inclined. So what they meant by God sometimes was radically different from each other. And then when you enter the modern period and we're talking the last 200, 300 years, you get new questions being asked of all kinds of religious traditions about science and the evidence and archaeology and geology, that questions how old the world is and did this actually happen the way the Hebrew Bible says it did? Once you start asking those questions, you're going to come sometimes to more secular conclusions. And the challenge is, of course, some of those secular conclusions apply to today. You know, I go to a doctor, I don't go for magical healing from a priest, but then it becomes applied backwards because if there isn't a God that heals people today, then maybe there wasn't a God even back then. And I have to understand those foundational narratives as stories, but not necessarily history. Just as Greek culture has its myths, maybe Jewish culture has its myths and stories that aren't a literal, verbatim depiction of what actually happened in those times and places. So that's how we look back at Jewish history, sources, scripture and so on as the stories of our people. The. But as stories and not necessarily history. [00:04:58] Speaker D: So is. And [00:04:59] Speaker B: so I would say [00:05:01] Speaker D: yes, please go ahead. [00:05:04] Speaker B: I was just going to add to what Adam has said, which is that humanistic Judaism takes a non theistic approach. It's not, you know, there are atheists certainly, but the God figure from the Hebrew Bible is a character and that character is named God. And so we sort of view it that rather than the idea that God created human beings instead that human beings created God. And that area of what was not understandable or explainable in ancient times, I think was attributed to God. And as we have moved forward in history, that area of things that were less explainable now science has filled that gap. But being Jews, we still want to be part of our ancestry and our history and our tradition, but we want to do it in a secular way [00:06:04] Speaker D: and does the humanist part. I guess, for me, when I think about humanism, it encapsulates all of humanity, all people. And so it's interesting to see, like, humanistic Judaism because it sort of is saying human, but a small segment of that, because it is just this culture, just this people group. How [00:06:32] Speaker E: do [00:06:32] Speaker D: you view other humans in this framework? [00:06:37] Speaker E: Well, a couple of pieces. One is we certainly take the approach of human rights, which is that every human being, as a human being, has rights that should be respected, a sense of dignity and purpose in their own lives, and a sense of being in control of their own lives and having the right to have a voice in their government and democracy and so on. So the human rights approach is something that we share with many people of many religious traditions. We can also draw inspiration from other people responding to the human experience. You see, for us, Judaism is how Jews have responded to the realities of the human experience. People die, we get sick, we look for inspiration. And Jews have responded to that reality in certain ways. Vocabulary, symbols, rituals, and so on. Other cultures have done that too, and that's wonderful for them. I heard a scholar once describe Judaism as like a piccolo in an orchestra. You know, every culture has their distinct style and tone and whatever. And even if we're just the piccolo, if we don't play the piccolo, there will be no piccolo, and that will be a unique approach to the human experience that will be lost. So we can play our piccolo. We don't want to play it so loudly that it drowns out the whole orchestra. Right. We're not the only approach to the human experience, and we can learn from others. But at the same time, there's a dignity and a purpose and a transcendence that we get from exploring how our people have responded to the human condition and finding a sense of connection across time with that response to what all people go through. So our humanism, through our Judaism, is using lessons from Jewish culture and phrases, inspiration to make us better human beings, not just in our little bubble of Jewishness. [00:08:22] Speaker B: And I think one of the questions that you're asking is the difference between particularism and universalism. And we address that in our book, Contemporary Humanistic Beliefs, Values and Practices, because there are parts that will feel very particular even as we are embracing a humanist philosophy. And as Adam was saying, you know, the idea of we encounter death, well, what are some of the rituals that we do and that are uniquely Jewish? And those are very comforting because we feel a little bit embraced by our tradition and Then there are those aspects, like human rights, that are very universal. And so what perhaps, can we look to our tradition to bring to that discussion that is broader than just a Jewish perspective? [00:09:15] Speaker D: And how does humanistic Judaism define morality or ethics without the presence of God or a deity or a religious context? [00:09:29] Speaker B: Sure. So you don't need God to be a good person. I mean, that's sort of the fundamental foundational premise that human beings have free will. Some will be good and some will not be good. And so in order to behave ethically, it's what is good for the advancement, if you will, of the betterment of the world of human beings. And really a belief that human beings are going to sort of come down on the right side. I don't want to sound naive about that because I fully recognize that there is bad and evil in the world, but that there's bad and evil in the world for people who believe in God. Right. People are still going to behave badly. So instead, it really is a faith, if you will, in human beings to opt for betterment of more people than just themselves. [00:10:29] Speaker E: I would also add that conventionally, people think religion provides ethics, either because there's a commander who's telling you exactly what to do and what not to do, or there's a supervisor who's watching what you're doing, and he knows if you've been sleeping and he knows if you're awake, and he knows if you've been bad or good. I mean, we're sort of laughing that it sounds like Santa Claus, but really that's the concept of a God imposing ethics. But the reality is that most people are good or bad based on the effects, the consequences they see of their behavior, how it affects other people and how it affects themselves, too. They don't do it because somebody's watching them. That's like relying on a parent or flock supervision cameras to make sure people do good things. They do it because they have a sense of their own internal ethics. That's that conscience that Jodi was referencing. And also because people have been trying to figure out how to live together since there have been people. You know, we're not inventing this from scratch. The whole idea of ethics and values comes out of all kinds of human cultures. And some are claimed to be based on a God. But what a coincidence that so many cultures everywhere around the world say, don't murder. Maybe it's because human society works better if you have a rule about not killing each other, and some have put it in the mouth of a God and said God said this. But this is why we can read the Torah and not like have an allergic reaction to all the God stuff in there. Because our perspective is that people said that God said don't do this. And we can agree or sometimes disagree because after all the, that God prohibited shellfish and allowed slavery. Well, so maybe that God didn't have our sense of values of good and bad. It was people at that time and place projecting onto a God what they thought was good and bad. And we have to evaluate what from that inheritance still speaks to us. What do we define as good and bad and how do we project that into the world, teach our kids and help enforce it. [00:12:31] Speaker D: And that is a more honest look, I think at the history and also at the, the books that we have evolved culturally. That's one thing that I have found a lot of people in different religions sort of gloss over or don't want to discuss. When you look at the Old Testament in the Bible, for example, and there's things, there's certain rules in Deuteronomy or Leviticus and like no Christians follow those in America. Like there's, there's just rules that, well, that was done away with. There's always a rationalization and I understand that's, that's the belief. But it's interesting that you're taking a more reality based approach to this of, well, this is where we are today. This is where they were back then when they wrote this. You know, the historical artifacts that we have. And so we're going to look at defining what protects and promotes life today. And that's where the morality can come from. But do you think people are capable of that responsibility without having a deity or a religious framework to tell them what to do and how to define their morality? [00:13:43] Speaker E: Well, existentialist, I'm sorry, existentialist philosophy starts with the premise that we are condemned to be free, right? We're stuck in this world and we don't have an authoritative cosmic voice speaking because after all, whatever someone says God said, they said God said it. And then of course there's always people called clergy who get to tell you what it actually means. So there's always a human mediated process. It's not like we're getting burning bushes popping up all over the place telling you what to do. So because there's always going to be a human element involved, you can project what you think people should do onto a God and almost like a puppet, you know, you're telling people what to do, be a God or claiming to speak for God. But if you instead rely on human discovery of human behavior, genetics, social sciences, as well as the experience of philosophy and what people have thought about in terms of motivating people to be good. If you look at the most secular societies out there, mostly the Scandinavian countries, Japan and some other places, their behavior actually tends to be pretty good on crime levels, on quality of life, reporting happiness. There's a wonderful sociologist named Phil Zuckerman who's done a number of studies on these societies. He wrote a book called Society Without God and he pointed out the more secular the society, often the happier people are and the better quality of life they have. So it doesn't take God to make that happen, it takes people to make that happen. [00:15:11] Speaker B: Yeah. And I would add that because we are evidence based and we're going to take a look at what, what science might help us to understand. There are millions of secular people, secular Jews, right, that are behaving in very moral and very ethical ways without subscribing to a belief in God that it isn't going to change how they are going to behave. Those people, they might be agnostics, they're not sure. Or a term that Rabbi Sherwin Wein, who founded Humanistic Judaism, called agnostics, which is, there may be a God or there may not be a God, but it's not going to change how I behave. And so we take a look at that evidence and science in the social sciences and social psychology, they're discovering that people sort of have an empathy gene that just through the evolution of the human mind, and as we alluded to earlier, people have to learn to live together. And they have had to do that from the start of time. And so having an empathy gene to try and understand, here's how, what I'm doing, but how does that make somebody else feel or to understand what somebody else is going through, that's all going to lead to a moral society and to an ethical society. And I would also add that every form of religion it appears, has a version of the golden rule. Love your neighbor as yourself. Right. Treat others as you would have them treat you. That's really fundamentally human. You know, it might be cast in religious texts, but it really is fundamentally human. [00:16:52] Speaker D: So why do we default to tribalism then, I guess would be my question. Why is it necessary? And I can be neutral on it, but I think that it's very much a human tendency to be tribal. And in this case, you can correct me if this is not the right way to couch it, but I think that saying we are Jewish people of Jewish descendants, and this is our tribe. And so we're combining that with humanism that is very tribal. And it's too, and this isn't a negative thing, but being tribal means you're excluding other people who are not in that group in a certain sense. So how do you combine the, the benefits of tribalism? Because there is something natural about being with people who think like us, look like us, talk like us, enjoy the same ceremonies and cultural things. But also how can you combine that with the broader empathy for other people groups who perhaps believe and think and look completely different? [00:17:58] Speaker E: So there's a wonderful concept by the. I think he's at Princeton, a sociologist named Appiah A. P. Piah. He wrote a book called Rooted Cosmopolitans. And the idea is that you can be cosmopolitan, the universal city, open to all kinds of cultures and experiences, but you're rooted in the people that you come from and the culture that you live in and the place that you were raised. You grew up with holidays and cultural attachments and sports allegiances and all these other tribalisms that we have. Now you can come out of that in a parochial, limited, closed way, or you can come out of that with an open minded approach that says, oh, we have these coming of age ceremonies. What are your coming of age ceremonies in your culture? As opposed to claiming ours is the right one and everyone else is wrong. You're finding the parallels in other people's rootedness in their cultural and cultural identities. I sometimes compare it to ethnic food. I would much rather have really authentic Chinese and Mexican restaurants than Applebee's, which is just this sort of bland version of softened for the American palate, sometimes crossover foods. There's an authenticness to that rootedness that doesn't mean you're chauvinist. You can value your family without being like a mafia that only cares about the family and doesn't treat anyone else well. I love my parents and my kids in a way that I don't love other people. And so I can feel connected to the Jewish people in ways that are different than connecting to humanity as a whole. 8 billion people is a lot of people to try to connect to. 16 million is more my scale of people that I can make sense of. [00:19:42] Speaker B: Yeah. And I think one of the things that humanistic Judaism does really, really well is that we are very inclusive, we are very welcoming. So if there's a family that comes from two different faith traditions, whichever spouse, parent, partner is not from the Jewish tradition, they're fully welcome. They're full participants, they participate in their children's B Mitzvah just as much as a person who was born Jewish. And that open welcoming, without judgment and without a prerequisite of saying, well, you can only participate if you do the following and you convert and you, at first you study and then you convert and then you, you know, you have to go through all these legal requirements to be a part of the community. That's very off putting. You know, I often want, I mean, I, I was born Jewish, my late husband was born Jewish, but we raised our kids as humanistic Jews. I came from the conservative movement. He came from sort of a conservadox movement where extended family was Orthodox, but he himself was raised in a Reformed congregation. I can't imagine being a part of. And so I came to humanistic Judaism, but I can't imagine raising our children in a way that would have privileged one parent over the other just because of their ancestral birth. That makes no sense to me. And so humanistic Judaism is in answer to your question of the tribal aspect. Yes, we have this collective historic memory, if you will, of Jewish ancestors, but we also understand that families are made up of multiple traditions and they're developing their own traditions, which is so lovely and beautiful. [00:21:44] Speaker D: So. Well, first question, do you believe in God of any type? And second, if not, if this is something that is just the human evolution over time of sort of a biological, material thing that's happening, like you were saying, history changes, morals change throughout different periods of time. But if there's also bringing in people from outside in a way to where someone who is not Jewish marries someone who is Jewish, then over time, over centuries, over millennia, then it seems like you begin to get something much more interwoven with other tribes, with other groups. And yet there still is that thread of Jewish history, but there's also many other things woven into that. How do you approach both of those things? One, the biological aspect, and the other one, I guess maybe is a separate question, but about belief in God or some sort of creator or a divine intervention on this planet that sort of set things in motion? [00:22:52] Speaker B: Sure. So I personally do not believe in God. And I, you know, when I teach my Sunday school kids, if they're going to ask me that question directly, I answer them directly. I don't try and hedge. I have kids and families, some of whom will say, I don't believe in God either. And I think they feel supported in being able to say that. And then I have other ones who say, you know, I do believe in God. And my answer is, well, that's, I'm happy for you that you are reaching your own conclusions. You know, so I can be a humanistic Jew and a rabbi and an atheist and not impose my own viewpoint so much as expose my viewpoint and let people learn, kids especially, learn to be critical thinkers. [00:23:41] Speaker E: Let me jump in on this and we'll get to the ethnic question. Second, I much prefer to define myself by what I do believe instead of what I don't believe. It's like the pro life, pro choice movement. They're not the anti choice, anti life movement. So I define myself as a humanist. I have positive beliefs in what people can know and do in the world that we have to rely on what people can know and do to make the world a better place. There's no cosmic justice coming down to smite the wicked. We have to do it. And if the suffering is to be reduced in the world, it has to be people that act to do that. So I prefer to focus on the positive beliefs in human power and responsibility rather than whether there is or isn't something before the Big Bang. Honestly, the most true answer I can give to that question is I don't know. That's true. You could say God. But you don't know. No, I know no, that I don't believe that. I don't know what's happening before the Big Bang. And as for the ethnic question, I have a spoiler alert. Jewish people have always mixed with other peoples. There's a reason why the Jews from Yemen look different from the Jews from Iraq. And the Jews from Iraq look different from the Jews in North Africa. And the Jews in North Africa look different from the Jews from Poland. They look different not because of the air, not because of the food and not because of the water. They look different because they met local people and they married local people. So there's always been mixing of Jewish culture with other cultures and Jewish people with other peoples. So this is a new phase in that. But it's not brand new in Jewish history or in Jewish life. We've always found a way to bring in multiple peoples into this umbrella called the Jewish people. I mean, we have this issue in American politics today over what is the American people and who's a real American. The idea of a peoplehood is an open peoplehood. It includes many ethnic, biological, genetic backgrounds that identify with a common culture and values. And so that's our sense of Jewish peoplehood is this broad understanding. It's also non exclusive. That is, you can identify as Jewish and something else, it's not Jewish. Or, you know, just like you could be, I don't know, Irish and African American. Right. That those aren't seen as you have to pick one or the other necessarily. The same is true for Jewishness. You can be Jewish and another ethnic identity, another cultural identity. We don't insist that you have to pick one or the other. And sometimes you get two people who are Jewish and something else who marry and then they produce their own conglomeration of identities in their household. Sometimes they marry someone who's fully Jewish, whatever that means, and they create their own choice of constellations. You get two people who are four Jewish grandparents who might do nothing Jewish at home. So just doing it by biology, that doesn't work. Just doing it by the genetic descent or family tree, that doesn't work, you know, 23. AndMe doesn't define how Jewish you are. You define how Jewish you are. And that's why we accept families of many constellations of identities. And also we affirm the fact that an individual can choose to identify with being Jewish. And we accept and celebrate that joining of the Jewish people by self declaration. [00:26:56] Speaker B: And I want to fully echo what Adam said about defining by what we do believe in. Okay, I was answering your question very directly because what I find is that if you say to somebody, I don't believe in God, it tends to be a conversation stopper because they say, well, I do. And [00:27:18] Speaker E: the [00:27:18] Speaker B: end, the end, we have nothing else to talk about. But if I say, well, I'm a humanist and I believe in the power and authority of human beings over their own lives, often I will get, well, I believe that too. You know, I believe that people are free to make choices and make ethical choices and then they, oh, I believe that too. Right. And now it's a conversation starter. Now we've defined and can continue to move forward with our common ground. And it's. And it is so much more empowering to be able to say what you do believe in rather than what you don't. And that tends to have a bit of defensiveness to it. [00:27:56] Speaker D: And that's much more productive too. Absolutely. And from, from what I was reading, the humanistic Judaism really puts an emphasis on defining the words correct. So that you are doing that in a positive way as opposed to, as you were saying, like not saying, oh, these are the things that we don't agree with, but saying, well, these are what we believe. And so then we're going to live those beliefs. So it's a way of perhaps making it more consistent to be living with integrity. Is that kind of the purpose? [00:28:32] Speaker E: Absolutely, [00:28:32] Speaker B: yes. Yes. And I think you really hit on a really important word for humanistic Jews is integrity, that we say what we mean, we mean what we say, and we don't pretend. [00:28:43] Speaker E: One example we include in the book is an adaptation of a traditional Jewish song prayer passage, where traditionally you're praising a God who makes peace in his heights and on and for all of Israel. It's a song called Osei Shalom that Jewish listeners will be familiar with, at least religious Jewish listeners will be familiar with. But we've adapted that instead of Osei shalom, he will make peace. We sing Naase shalom, We will make peace alenu for us vaal kol ha olam and for all the world, not just for our people, Israel. And then at the end, instead of saying Amen, which the traditional song does, we sing Shalom, which says what we want to see in the world is the peace. But the key point is that shift from he will make peace in his heights to we will make peace in the world. That's the shift from God acting to people and from above and beyond to this world here and now. [00:29:38] Speaker D: Do you get pushback from other components or other. I'm not sure what the word is. Denominations or sects within Judaism that are more Orthodox, that are more traditional religious, is. Is there conflict there? And how is that resolved, considering that you have the cultural foundation, similarities? [00:30:00] Speaker E: The answer is yes. [00:30:02] Speaker B: The answer is yes. The answer is yes. And depending how much toward the Orthodox side of things, I would say I get it twice because I'm a humanistic Jew and I'm a woman. And so there are some circles that say, well, if you're a woman, you can't be a rabbi [00:30:21] Speaker E: of any kind. [00:30:21] Speaker B: Of any kind. Right. In any denomination. Fortunately, that changed. In the more liberal denominations of Judaism, women are ordained all the time. But yes, as Adam was saying, the short answer is yes, there's pushback. There's. How can you be Jewish and not believe in God? God, or how can you. What we prefer to say, you know, we're Jewish, like beyond God, like God isn't the central issue of our Judaism, but it's a very rich and meaningful form of Judaism. [00:30:55] Speaker D: And are you able to bring that together as far as some resolution and some common ground, or is it just [00:31:01] Speaker E: now, well, look, there. There are some people you're never going to reach. And so you have to decide, am I going to live my life by what they want me to do or Am I going to live my life by my values and what's important to me? You know, I have this conversation with people becoming Jewish sometimes to say, well, will the Orthodox recognize me? And I say, well, you have to decide, do you want to live an Orthodox life? Because if you're living by what their standard is, it's not your life. If these are your values, what we represent, then we recognize you, we welcome you, and you don't live your life based on other people's standards. And so I do that in my rabbinate as well. Now. It's better, way better now than it was 40, 50, 60 years ago when our movement was founded. Back then, the rabbis who were leading humanistic Jewish communities in Detroit and Chicago, two of the largest ones, they were Persona non grata at boards of rabbis because they were willing to officiate at marriages between Jewish and non Jewish people. They were sometimes condemned publicly by their colleagues. We have none of those issues. We're welcome. As members of the Chicago Board of Rabbis, I have colleagues that I'll meet with socially and get along just fine. Now do I go seeking out lots of Orthodox rabbis to get their endorsement? No, I don't need to do that because they're living their life and I'm living my life. There's a Yiddish phrase, gesunder hate, which means go and do your life and enjoy a healthy life, but leave me alone and I'll leave you alone. There's always going to be Jewish arguments like there's something definitive in Jewish culture about arguing with each other. Even in the Talmud, they're arguing with each other all the time. So that's not going to change. It's very Jewish actually to disagree and argue, but we can still feel part of one shared Jewish community and sometimes find common cause on certain issues or values. So whether it's confronting antisemitism or dealing with issues related to protesting Israel, depending on where you land on that particular issue, you can find common cause with other Jews from other denominations where the God issue is less important than the feeling part of this people at approach. And if they're pluralistic minded people, which you can find from Orthodox Conservative Reform reconstructing, you can find all variety of open minded people that accept diversity. They'll welcome us too. And the closed minded people who draw lines, I don't live based on their judgment. [00:33:21] Speaker D: So what happens? You mentioned being a rabbi. In my, in my mind I'm thinking of someone who is a religious leader who sort of leads the, the reads scripture or leads a service. I'M not sure if you call it that, but when you get together, what happens? Do you get together weekly? Is it. Is it more of a social time? Do you talk about social issues that impact the Jewish community, or do you. Do you read scripture and talk about. Even though you're not saying that God said this, but you talk about the moral concepts that are there or some of the parables, like what. What happens in your congregations? [00:34:02] Speaker B: So. So we're leaders, we're teachers, we're life cycle ceremonialists, meaning that, you know, somebody needs a funeral officiated or conducted, needs a wedding to be officiated, needs a B Mitzvah to be officiated, that we do all of that. I teach a monthly Bible class, reading the Bible as literature and reading it in English, so that everybody who's participating is going to fully understand it. Run a Sunday school so that our kids are going to be able to learn their history, their stories, their ancestry and their holidays in broad terms. So we do all of that. We sort of, I think, do everything that you would otherwise think a rabbi would do. We just do it. I shouldn't say we just do it. We do it in the movement and denomination known as Humanistic Judaism. [00:35:06] Speaker E: And I will answer your ceremony question. We sometimes use ceremony instead of service because we're not really serving anybody. But sometimes we use service because that's what people mean when they're talking about what you do for Rosh Hashanah or for Shabbat or for other holidays. What you would see at a humanistic Jewish service is many of the same symbols of sharing wine or lighting candles or sharing challah bread on a Friday night, hearing a shofar, the ram's horn be blown at the Jewish New Year. So we include many of those same symbols that would be recognizable in terms of the content of the service. We generally mix Hebrew and English or other Jewish languages as well. Largely the prose or poetry readings are in English, again for comprehension and inspiration. But we'll have music that includes other Jewish languages or Hebrew and English verses to the songs for that cultural roots connection. Our goal is to provide both a sense of roots, but also inspiration and uplift. We will do commentaries on Jewish source readings, which could be Torah, Hebrew Bible or modern Jewish literature, too. We're not restricted, you know, our. In some ways, we like to say our ark is wider. It includes the Torah, but also other Jewish literary creativity that's more recent. And so you'll see those sources. But yes, we do also talk about current events. I just did a talk Last week on the challenges of AI and how we can address them. Because after all, we believe in human dignity. And maybe that empowers people to be more in charge of their life, but also it takes over your life and changes the price you pay for something because the AI is two steps ahead of you. So we have to find the right balance of empowerment and powerlessness in response to this golem, this monster that we've created that might destroy the world. We don't know yet. So these are current events that we can have a humanistic and Jewish perspective on that can be part of our ceremonial life and calendar, too. We'll do Torah readings, but not necessarily defined by the traditional Torah portion for the week, because, again, our arc is wider. We can draw from more sources than only the same five books read over and over again. [00:37:14] Speaker D: And do people keep the Sabbath and wear any of the ceremonial clothing? Or. I forget the name of the hat. I'm sorry, the [00:37:27] Speaker E: kippa or yarmulke. [00:37:28] Speaker B: Yeah, [00:37:30] Speaker D: do, do you also do that? Or is that something that is optional or is it something that is not done because it is religious in nature? [00:37:40] Speaker B: I would say it's optional and personal. So the, the, the founders of humanistic Judaism, in establishing something brand new, took a little bit of a hard line in order to say, okay, if you're a humanistic Jew, don't [00:37:58] Speaker E: do [00:37:58] Speaker B: that, don't do that. Right. Don't wear a kippah, don't wear a tallit, a prayer shawl. Now, there's discussion among members in different communities that say, you know what? I want to be visibly identifiable as Jewish. I want to have that in common. And so they may put on a kippah that if we use tallit, the prayer shawl, they have fringes on it. So we're not. If somebody is opting to wear it, it's not to humble themselves before God. But it often, in a B Mitzvah ceremony, for instance, it tends to be an heirloom item. This belonged to the grandpa, the great grandpa. Right. It was bought in Israel when the child was born, just for this very day. And what I say is that the fringes tie the generations together. So we take the ritual object, but now we're reinterpreting it and we give an alternative and we say things out loud because otherwise it's going to look like, oh, well, if you do this there, then how are you really different than the conservative movement? Because they're all putting on tallytuh. Right? So we make sure that we're not going to be misunderstood. [00:39:11] Speaker E: Right. The question is ultimately, why are you doing it because you feel commanded to do it, or are you doing it because it's part of your cultural roots and connection? It's your tribal garb, as one of our leaders calls it. And if that's your meaning to it, then again, you're in charge of your life and you're choosing from your cultural library. After all, lighting Shabbat candles are also commanded by tradition. And so it would be sort of inconsistent to light the candles and call that cultural, but then say the clothing is not cultural, but they come from a similar root. So letting people make their own choices is something we've evolved to in our movement, where, as Jodi said, in the early generations, we said not to do that. In terms of observing Shabbat, in terms of private life, that's really up to individuals. I mean, there are all kinds of people who do what you call a tech Shabbat. Like, they take these devices that consume our lives and turn them off, off, off [00:40:01] Speaker D: for [00:40:01] Speaker E: 24 hours. Amazing experience. [00:40:05] Speaker D: It's probably very hard [00:40:06] Speaker E: to do, but imagine what kind of an experience that would be to have that time. And they'll use lights and they'll flush toilets, and they'll do things that traditionally you wouldn't do on a observant Shabbat basis, but they're finding their way of approaching it. I had a friend in college who wouldn't do homework on Shabbat. That was his creating a space of rest for what he needed to rest from. So having a creative approach to what Shabbat. I mean, and for some people, it's a family dinner on Friday night. And that's a. For some people, it's not even that. It's a time period they know of, or maybe they come to a service once in a while. We have services at my congregation maybe three out of four Fridays in a month. And so they could come and attend that. We do them also hybrid online. So if you don't want to even leave your house, you put on the zoom and watch the service that way. But the reality is it's up to people to choose if it's meaningful to them, and if so, how they want to draw from that cultural library of options to pick the pieces that work for them. [00:41:04] Speaker B: And I think choice is what's really important. And that if we sort of zoom out and get away from the intricacies and the legal requirements that the tradition might have imposed for, say, observing Shabbat, and you don't drive and you don't do any of that. And we pan out and say there might be value to having a day of rest to get away from all the busyness of our everyday lives. You know, I like to tell the story that when my kids were growing up, I had a dry erase calendar and everybody had a head of color. And so that way I could just take a quick look and I would know who had to be where and what was going on. And if I had a Tuesday that had no color, nobody had to be anywhere. I called it Shabbat. It was going to be a respite. It was going to be, oh my gosh, we can all eat dinner together. Right? So we kind of take a look at not just the very particular, here's a Shabbat, but what was the value of Shabbat? What was it trying to fulfill? And in our modern lives, some of that messaging could still be very relevant and very healthy. [00:42:21] Speaker D: Absolutely. And you mentioned AI and technology. I think that's an interesting sort of pathway for the evolution of where we are going as humanity, both within the Jewish community and just the broader planet Earth. What is your, your view on AI in terms of optimism or pessimism? Or is it. Do you think it's simply a tool that like any technology that we can continue to use, or is it something that you take a more, a more serious look at of? This can be really a catalyst to continue our evolution as a species as long as we do xyz, to make sure that it doesn't take over or that certain other people groups don't take it over and then use that against everybody else, et cetera. [00:43:20] Speaker E: Well, I think the dilemma is I used the story to introduce my talk on this of the golem, which is an old Jewish legend about a. Basically, the fancy word is homunculus, an artificial being that was created out of clay that then ran amok and was killing people everywhere until they finally were able to stop the golem. It's, you know, it's a Terminator, right? It's just, it's running loose. And the dilemma with AI is that before the golem went amok, it was very useful and helpful. And then it went, then it ran amok. So AI is both dangerous and very useful. Both are true. And the dilemma becomes, does it enhance human dignity or undermine human dignity? Does it help us realize human potential, or does it dehumanize us as serving the machine? So I heard a story recently, I think it was featured on Jon Stewart's podcast about how AI offers competitive bidding to nurses to try to get them to accept less lower wages for shifts based on their credit reports. So it studies their credit reports, sees who's in more debt, and offers them a lower wage because they figure they have to accept it. It's a way of keeping costs down for the hospital. But it's horribly unethical and demeaning and undermining of human dignity. But you can see how AI could do that. Now, AI can also do a wonderful job of crunching large bodies of data. If you wanted to find out, for example, how did districts vote in the latest congressional election that happened to have a Cheesecake Factory restaurant in the district? It turns out Cheesecake Factory restaurant districts voted plus Democrats, I think, plus 30 points or something like that. Now that's sort of funny because of the whole Cheesecake Factory thing, But the amount of data you'd have to crunch to do that, because you'd have to get all the restaurant locations and then apply them to the. But AI can do it amazingly quickly. And you know, that's not necessarily useful information, but you can imagine doing that kind of data crunching very usefully to do things. So this is the dilemma with AI, that it can be tremendously useful in diagnosis and computer coding, but it can also be disastrous in terms of human dignity and thriving. So this is where we really need guardrails. We need people to be looking at this with a. A question of not just what can it do, but what should it do? And that's where a humanistic, ethical approach is valuable. I love open road tolling. I don't need toll booths with people standing there. I love even the self checkout at the grocery store. I still find it kind of cool that you scan the code and it beeps and there it is. Because I remember when you had to manually key it in a long time ago. I use the ATM at the bank, right? I don't insist on a person. So I'm not opposed to technology making our lives easier and simpler and sometimes replacing human jobs. But we need to do it with an eye to human dignity and human thriving. And I think all too often the AI companies are pursuing what they can do and not thinking about what they should do. [00:46:33] Speaker D: So transhumanists would look at the advance or the joining together with technology of utilizing that to sort of evolve us as humans. And there are some views that, that we're doing that biologically and that we're going to super seed humanity. And there's other views that take a more religious component of, well, we're going to, we're birthing these conscious intelligent beings, basically. What would your approach be to giving rights to AI or to robots that are run by AI? Because there will be arguments that come. You're talking about human dignity. And, and I personally agree with that. But I can also see where these arguments are going to come and they're going to say, well, yes, I'm also a humanist, but I believe that we're going to evolve humanity. And so the robots also need to be treated with respect and dignity. And now because they're smarter than us, now those people are actually, or those robots are more important to society and to the evolution of the species than the nurse with the really bad credit report who's having to pay more. So ethically I'm going to side with the robots. Where would humanistic Judaism be stand on that? If, if let's say it was a Jewish company or a Jewish person that had the robots that were in question? [00:48:08] Speaker E: Well, that wouldn't, that wouldn't matter, right? Like that [00:48:10] Speaker D: wouldn't matter. [00:48:10] Speaker E: The identity of the person doing it. We're not cutting our own people more slack than anybody else. [00:48:15] Speaker D: Okay, [00:48:16] Speaker E: that kind of a question. I don't know if you wanted to jump in on this. [00:48:19] Speaker B: Yeah, go ahead, go ahead. [00:48:21] Speaker E: I know technology is more my department. I mean, there isn't a sort of consensus perspective on this. But in defining what counts as a full human being, this is an issue that has come up in other contexts. You think about end of life questions, you know, what is life worthy of life? Should people be able to choose physician assistance in dying, for example, if they decide their life is not worth living anymore and should there be a dignified way to handle that? What about someone with advanced dementia or other kinds of cognitive significant impairments? How does that apply to handicapped people? Because many people with who are disabled are opposed to these medical aid and dying rules because they're worried people are going to push them to end their lives and someone else is going to decide that their life is not worthy of living. So these are ongoing complex issues with people alone, let alone adding a non carbon based biological consciousness to that debate. So philosophers, legal scholars, they've been debating this and we're part of that category of debate now. I haven't yet heard of a robot asking for a bar mitzvah or looking to marry another robot or having those kind of human needs that people have that we try to serve. They tend not to have cultural roots. Right? That's part of the, part of the sandbox that we play in. So it hasn't really come to our inbox. They have to grapple with the humanity, or the Jewishness, for that matter, of a program. But I do see in the transhumanist conversation about taking humanity beyond just the biological, maybe uploading your consciousness to a machine or something like that. I mean, we are not just human anymore. I'm using these devices called glasses that augment my function. Some people have replacement knees. They have, you know, pacemakers. They have all kinds of devices that make life better. And so we're not just acquiescing to whatever nature says. That's part of science, technology, human discovery, and human thriving. I think in this case, though, if the machines do get consciousness, however we've defined that, it will be an interesting step to hurdle. I don't think we can stop progress in that direction, because, unfortunately, you can't. But we'll have to deal with that complexity. And it won't just be a Jewish question, and it won't just be a humanistic Jewish question. I think it'll be a human question, and we'll have to think about it as people, not just as one particular tradition. [00:50:52] Speaker B: And I would add, and Adam's right, that as between the two of us, tech stuff is, like, definitely over there. But I think that older people in particular, there's an epidemic of loneliness and social isolation that is not good for them for physical health, for mental health. And I would much rather recognize that as an issue and have human beings intervene and bring somebody lunch or go spend an hour and have an actual conversation than to have somebody look for a, quote, spiritual leader that is completely AI generated and have conversation that that is meant to assuage their loneliness. So I think that there are ways that if we identify the human need, that that really cannot be replaced with technology. [00:51:56] Speaker E: Although I will add that the world of zoom has improved and has addressed to some extent that challenge. You know, when we were locked in our Covid houses and couldn't even touch other people, so we thought we had this way of connecting and way of feeling part of a community. We still, as I said, offer hybrid services. Some people want to come in person. Some people are sick and they want to stay home, but they want to stay connected. We have members that are older that don't drive at night, but they can connect on a zoom to see a Shabbat service and to share what's going on in their lives and to hear other people talk so technology can meet those human needs in new, innovative ways. But I agree with Jodi that talking to a machine that's an AI imitator of human connection may work to answer factual questions. I'm not sure it's going to answer the loneliness challenge or the desire to connect with other people in the same way. [00:52:57] Speaker D: It's an interesting thing that I've sort of bumped up against more and more in these conversations of the difference in thinking between those who are more just pro human but within their framework and those who are more traditional also within their framework. Because I guess by definition the traditional is, is a little bit more put on the brakes. You know, we, we don't necessarily want to change and yet all of us, anybody that lives in modern society is dealing with these changes. There's very few people, perhaps the Amish, maybe there are some Orthodox Jews who still live in the same way where they don't drive cars or use technology. But I think there's very few groups around the world today that, that live that way who say, no, we're, we're truly going to stay conservative and you know, in the, in this place that we believe is correct, but for the rest of it, the philosophical belief systems or even religious belief systems, where people are saying, I do believe in God, I am seeking God, but I also understand that as a human there's growth and change that's happening across our planet and within me. And so I have a responsibility to kind of continue to grow and learn and evolve. I think it's very interesting that you're taking a unique approach, I would say, within the Jewish community to the aspect of being Jewish and also looking at the traditions through, I guess, a new lens. Yeah, because you're saying how can we bring it into the future? Not simply how can we live in the present with all of these things from the past, but how can we take our roots and continue to grow the, the tree into the future in a way that still remains the, the core type of tree that we are. [00:55:03] Speaker E: I don't know that we're unique necessarily because there are other liberal approaches to Judaism, Reform Judaism, reconstructing Judaism, Jewish renewal, that are explicitly non traditional in many ways. They ordain women, they accept the lgbtq, they've opened their doors to intermarried families and even people from intermarried families to become rabbis. I mean, these are dealing with the same reality that we are and we with a similarly open and welcoming way up to a point, we may be a little bit more in some ways, but we're not the only ones trying to live with a foot in the modern world. And A foot connected to Jewish tradition. And that's why we sometimes argue. You mentioned the question of will people accept you or not. I try to make the point that we are part of a tradition of Jewish change in the modern world, part of this trend. I mean, think of Jewish feminists who have changed the language of Jewish prayers to refer to a female God figure, to say, you in the feminine form and not in the masculine form. In their prayers, they're changing the tradition, reflecting their beliefs and values and what speaks to them. So the fact that we're changing it in a secular direction as opposed to a feminine God, it's still change. So I like to draw on those examples, to point out that we're not as radical as some people think we are in trying to bridge the modern world and our values and being willing to change things. [00:56:27] Speaker B: Yeah. And we have a colleague in Israel who maintains that as humanistic Jews, we're very traditional because what we're doing is very true to the tradition. We are changing things. We are reinterpreting. It's always been plural Judaisms throughout our historic experience. And so she says, yeah, we're very traditional. [00:56:52] Speaker D: Is this something that is unique to Judaism? I'm thinking of if there's other, because it's. You have the religious history aspect, but also the cultural people aspect. And it seems that most other major religions or philosophical frameworks are less about the ancestral heritage of the people who believe them and more about the. The roots of the movement or the structure. [00:57:26] Speaker E: It depends on the tradition. I mean, if you think of Native American traditions, they have a sense of peoplehood and sort of the ethnic continuity of the group, in addition to the, you know, theological belief system and structure. And. And also there are a lot of parts of the world where their religiousness and their ethnic identity are very tightly connected. I think of Polish Catholics or Italian [00:57:49] Speaker B: Catholics [00:57:50] Speaker E: or Arab Muslims, you know, where you can be Arab and Christian too, but the dominant religion in the Arab population is Islam. And there's. There's a roots in the Islamic origins in the Arabian Peninsula and Arabic language in the Quran. So you can have a conjunction of ethnicity and religion. And sometimes to the point that we had a faculty member at our institute who's from an Italian background. He happened to major and focus in Jewish studies, but he was a secular Italian. And yet when his group of Italian expats in Michigan got together, they did it on the feast days for the saints that were popular in Italy because those were holidays and that's. That's the day they were going to get together. So we're not unique in having that sort of ethno religious identity where things are kind of entangled with each other, but we're willing to both move beyond the religious constraints while also claiming it as part of our cultural inheritance. As Jodi said earlier, for us, religion is part of culture, but not the defining element. That's yes or no, what we do or don't do. Because our arc is, why do we include many more things in what counts as doing Jewish than just studying scripture and reciting prayers? It also is how we make the food. It also is the clothing that we wear at certain times. It's the languages we spoke, the music we enjoyed, the art we created. That's all part of our Jewishness. And that is a peoplehood thing that's inflected with religion, but it's like you can't separate it. You go back to the Book of Ezra, and he talked about the holy seed of Judea. Holy is religion, seed is ethnic. It's always been part of who we are. [00:59:40] Speaker D: Did you have something to add to that, Jody? Sorry. [00:59:42] Speaker B: No. No. [00:59:43] Speaker D: Okay. [00:59:44] Speaker B: That was. Well, well said. [00:59:46] Speaker E: Just say amen. Amen. [00:59:48] Speaker D: Do you said do. You say no, you don't say amen. You say shalom. Right? [00:59:52] Speaker E: Well, technically, [00:59:53] Speaker B: it [00:59:54] Speaker E: depends. [00:59:54] Speaker B: It depends. Some places. Some of our communities do. In certain contexts, we do. [00:59:59] Speaker E: Yeah. [00:59:59] Speaker B: And in other contexts, no, [01:00:01] Speaker E: literally, amen comes from the Hebrew word. I agree. Or like ditto, or [01:00:07] Speaker B: so be it [01:00:08] Speaker E: right on. Or, you know, whatever you want to translate it as. So it doesn't have to have a theological sense. But this is where it's on that you talked about defining words and what words you use or don't use or what symbols you use or don't use. It's one of those cases where it's sort of fuzzy. So we have some members that don't like the word blessed or blessing because they think of blessing as supernatural and God and. [01:00:31] Speaker B: And they bless Thor. [01:00:32] Speaker E: Right. And there's a blesser who's doing it. But if I say I bless, so and so maybe that works. Or maybe I'll use the word blessing, but not. Not talk about the blesser. I feel blessed could be supernatural, or it could be I feel fortunate, I feel lucky, I feel uplifted. So this is a vocabulary debate that I don't think will ever be ended. We have the same conversation with the new people who join and say, why are you saying this? Or why aren't you saying that? And we've been having it for 60 years since the movement started in the early 1960s. And it will continue as long as there are people migrating to a humanistic Judaism from somewhere else and making their own choices. You know, if I went into a synagogue that had everybody in a tallit and a kippah, I don't know that I would feel comfortable as a secular Jew, because the implication is they're doing it as sort of a collective identity of religiousness that. I mean, my family hasn't worn one. I was raised as a humanistic Jew, so I didn't grow up with it as something that I was culturally attached to. And so I might feel less comfortable in a setting where everyone did it. If a few people have it, then I know it's a choice and people are choosing to do it. But if everyone was wearing it, I might feel less comfortable. So it's sort of a degree question of how far do you go? If I say amen once in a while? If I say blessed once in a while. Okay. If I said amen, amen, amen, holy, holy, holy, blessed, blessed, blessed, then you might feel less comfortable. [01:02:00] Speaker D: It's interesting. [01:02:01] Speaker B: I [01:02:01] Speaker D: think [01:02:01] Speaker B: sometimes it's easier to take a look at another religion and things that you might feel comfortable with. So, you know, I've always felt that if I go, I have occasion to be in a church for a service, right. I will stand up out of respect. I will not kneel, because that's a sign of worship. Right. So if I were going into a Conservative synagogue and the feeling was, [01:02:26] Speaker E: it's required, [01:02:27] Speaker B: it's required. And women sometimes put a little circle of lace on their head and whatever, I would try and politely decline, but I would also understand that I am entering someone else's religious home and I need to be respectful then. So I will stand up for different prayers. I will not join in the prayers because that would compromise my integrity. [01:02:53] Speaker E: And I take off my shoes going in a mosque. [01:02:55] Speaker B: Yes. [01:02:55] Speaker E: That's respectful. [01:02:56] Speaker B: Yeah. [01:02:57] Speaker D: That's really interesting because I. I have experienced that myself in Catholics Mass where, because I'm not a Catholic, my wife, we just got married a couple years ago, and she's. She's very Catholic. And we have very different views, but we respect each other and our, you know, separate beliefs as far as that goes. But she had to tell me, like, hey, you don't have to do all these things when you come to Mass, like, because I go sometimes for special services or whatever. Like when we kneel, when we do these things, you can just stand. And that's the respectful thing. To do, don't sit down, but stand. And I was like, okay, I can do that. And it's always interesting to me to like, kind of like side eye, look around to see who else is standing, you know, who are the other pagans that are here in mass? And it's usually, it's usually just me and maybe like someone who's very, very elderly who can't kneel or sit, but they're obviously know, part of the service. But I think you are doing [01:03:55] Speaker E: something, you are doing something good in that you're supporting your spouse. [01:03:59] Speaker B: Yeah. [01:04:00] Speaker E: And that's. But [01:04:01] Speaker D: also for me [01:04:02] Speaker E: too, [01:04:03] Speaker D: it's something for me that in that moment I can choose how I'm going to respond to being there. And I don't have to do all of the things or believe any of it, but I can choose to be in a meditative state. I can choose to, to have that attitude of, you know, peace and calm and, and whatever it is in that moment of, of worshipfulness. But it's also respectful for, for the other people and not being a distraction. And I think the most important thing that you hit on is it keeps my integrity. And that is something that we had to work through on other things of like, look, I'll do a lot of things, I'll say a lot of things in life in general, but I have lines. And especially when it comes to the spiritual and my beliefs about these things, there's lines I'm just not going to cross, even if it's not politically the correct thing to do in the moment. And people will get mad because I just, I don't want to break my own integrity. And I think that that's a really important thing that people of all faiths and beliefs should do more of and say, look, this is what I believe. So it's not because I'm anti you. It's just because this is what I'm pro for me. And so this is why I'm going to make this choice respectfully. [01:05:23] Speaker E: One other approach I take when I go to other religious institutions is the anthropologist where I'm observing this ritual and I'm seeing what they're saying and why they're saying it. And I'm learning about the human experience. Again, they're, they're responding to the human experience too, their beliefs and value structures and so on. And I can learn something maybe about myself, about the world, about this tradition. So it's a learning exposure and not just, you know, I can participate up to a point, but at other times I have the remove of the observer, and I can still get something positive out of it. [01:05:55] Speaker B: Yeah. And when it's some. When it's not your own religion, I think sometimes that's a little easier. When it is, you know, if it's something that you once did and you've given up or you don't believe and you don't want to be doing that or whatever it is, sometimes that's a little harder. So I don't keep kosher, but I would not go to a Jewish home where they do and bring food that wasn't kosher, you know, and certified in some way. That would not be respectful. That would be inconsistent with my values of respecting the dignity of other human beings. And I think sometimes we. We don't necessarily tease that out. It's, you know, perhaps there's an assumption, well, if you're Jewish, then you keep kosher. And so whatever you brought is fine. You know, if we're going to carry that. That analogy further. But taking. Taking a step back, pausing and saying, oh, what can I do that could be respectful, dignified, and still maintain my integrity, that those are. Those are thought processes, they might go very quickly. It's not like I'm going to take a long time analyzing all of that. But within Judaism, sometimes that process has to. You have to go through that a little bit. Whereas you might say, oh, yeah, of course, I'm going to a church, I'm going to stand up, but that's respect. You know, [01:07:26] Speaker D: you mentioned the word blessing a little bit ago. I want to come back to that because I have something really interesting that ties into it. I spoke to a Franciscan monk in an earlier episode. We had a really interesting conversation, but one of the ways that he was talking about that they deal with conflict is if your brother is mad at you, if someone that you're talking to is mad at you, that you prostrate yourself in front of them and you say, not. Please forgive me. Not. I'm sorry, but you say, bless me. Bless me. And so it puts the onus on the other person to stop getting mad in that moment and then to choose whether they're going to walk away from the situation completely or whether. Whether they're going to bless you. Now, I was thinking about that, because when you mentioned that. That the blessing is coming from the person as opposed to the blessing coming from God, in their Franciscan view, I'm sure that they would be thinking of it as the person being a vessel probably for God's blessing coming through. But it's also a literal thing of changing the situation and reducing the conflict and bringing harmony human to human. So whatever the theology is behind what they. They believe that they're doing, it also could work from a secular perspective of like, instead of just, I'm sorry, please forgive me, and then it's like, yeah, sure, I forgive you, but you don't really forgive. Like, you can fake that, but it's kind of hard to fake blessing someone when you're mad at them. Right? And so I think it's. I was just curious when you were talking about blessing, that I was like, I want to see what your perspective is on that, because that could be something maybe that we need to do more of. Maybe not so exaggerated of prostrating yourself on the ground, but the idea of sort of putting yourself open hands in front of the person that you harmed or that you made angry and requesting that they, you know, they assume their dignity as a person and that you are giving your humility to them, I think that might have some positive impact on how we start to resolve conflict. And maybe it can be a metaphor for a larger way of connecting with people who believe differently or who we do have division with. [01:10:03] Speaker B: Yeah, that's a wonderful example. You know, and what it brings to my mind is when we celebrate the holiday of Yom Kippur and we forgive ourselves, then we ask forgiveness from other people. And with humanistic Judaism, that's the only level that we. That we go to. Right. In traditional Judaism, it would go one step further that after you have asked forgiveness from other people, then you're asking forgiveness from God. So you're right. I mean, it humbles you, it humbles the other person, and at least you've made the effort. I think that words like blessing, sacred, one of the hot button issues might be spiritual. You know, that I'm not willing to cede all that language to the Orthodox. I have blessings in my life. I am so grateful. Right? And I'm willing to acknowledge it and call them blessings. I didn't receive them from an external supernatural being, but I can recognize that. I can recognize the Torah as what I call our sacred mythology. And by sacred, I don't mean that I cannot interpret it. It means that I'm not going to rewrite it. I'm not going to start from the beginning and take God out at every single mention. This is what was written. And from my perspective, it's entitled to some respect, even if I'm interpreting it in a completely different way than somebody else who would be more religious. [01:11:44] Speaker E: If I can Jump in on the forgiveness thing. What it really reminded me of exactly what Jodi was saying about Yom Kippur is the value of having a long tradition that's thought about these kind of questions and not just inventing it from scratch. Because Maimonides, who wrote 800 years ago, was grappling with, what does it mean that I have to ask someone for forgiveness? What does it mean that I have to offer forgiveness to someone who's wronged me? Does that mean I have to make myself available for the people that wronged me to come find me and ask for forgiveness? That's uncomfortable. How many times do I have to go and ask them to forgive me before they'll forgive me, before I'm like, I've fulfilled my duty and I don't have to keep asking them forever? But he thought about this, and he wrote in his collection of Jewish laws what he recommended as the best way to deal with and how to approach them. You find a friend of theirs to come with you to vouch for you that you're really coming. So there's all this insight into the human condition and repairing relationships. That's part of that approach to the ceremony. Now, I don't fast for 26 hours. I don't need to. Part of Yom Kippur is lying yourself flat on the ground asking for God's forgiveness. I don't feel the need to do that. I don't feel dignified in doing that. And there are certain things that are not forgivable, that I'm not going to prostrate myself, no matter what. But the reality is that our tradition has thought about these questions and created a space, even a whole day, that's focused on repairing relationships with people. And also, as we've interpreted, turning instead of above and beyond turning inward to forgive ourselves. That's tremendously psychologically valuable. So that's where the Jewish cultural response to this issue has tremendous human psychological insight. And you can find examples of books that people have written where they talk about the Jewish approach to parenting or the Jewish approach to forgiveness. And they're drawing on these insights, but trying to apply it because they want to sell books to a broader audience. And that's fine, because they're taking this human exposure, human experience, and applying it to the human condition. So, you know, that Franciscan monk's example could be meaningful for anybody, not just for people from a Catholic background. [01:14:00] Speaker D: Jody, you mentioned words, and it seems like words have come up a few times here as being really important for humanistic Judaism. And I Was recalling the conversation that I had with a rabbi. I guess now it was last year, it was in the first season that I did this. And he was talking about the Word is God. And the reason that we debate the law is because. And Christians also believe this. Like in the beginning was the Word, and the Word was the God and the Word was God. So sort of drawing the connection there from on the secular side, words are very important because of beliefs and integrity. And in being able to define these things is key. Does. Does it come from like, the importance of words in your view? Does that come from the historical importance of the Word as sort of a. An artifact of like, the Word is God in Jewish tradition or is it more simply about. Words are important in modern society and language is how we are able to communicate and define things. And so therefore words are really key to defining what we believe and then also living it. [01:15:16] Speaker B: I would come down on the second one. Absolutely. I don't think that the importance of words in humanistic Judaism is because the original word in, you know, in Genesis, how was the world created? God said so, you know, not that sense. But the message I can get from the creation story is words must be so powerful that the storyteller and the biblical author said they can create an entire world. So that's how I would interpret words. But I'm not talking about the original God said, right, that word instead, in order to be clear, in order to speak with integrity and to, as I said earlier, you know, to say what I mean and mean what I say, which is a popular movement phrase. I think that that's the side that I come down on. That's why words are so important. That's why wordsmithing, what we want to say when we are writing a sermon or when we wrote the book, right? How did we want to present the different issues, the different aspects of humanistic Judaism? You know, we were. We were very much and very much encouraged to do, based on our manage, from our managing editor, to put things in a very positive way without casting shade on other denominations. You know, that shows our respect for other denominations, even if we disagree with some of their practices or the ways that they choose to believe. So it is absolutely a matter of integrity. [01:16:58] Speaker E: And what I found is that a lot of people find their way to humanistic Judaism because of language questions. They're sitting in the service in a Reform or Conservative synagogue and they're reading the translation of what's being said in Hebrew and they're saying to themselves, I just don't agree with this. And what am I doing here? Saying these words over and over again as if I do. There's a kind of cognitive dissonance there that feels wrong. And they feel like, well, you mean I can't light a menorah if I don't say things I don't believe? The only way to do it is to say these things I don't believe. No. So. So they look for something else. They don't just put up with it. They don't just try to redefine it in some way, or they don't just say, well, it's in Hebrew. I don't really care what it means. These are people who care what it means and who want to have a life where their values and their Judaism and their personal philosophy and their community identity are in harmony with each other. They coincide and collaborate and support each other and reinforce each other. So our students never have to come home from their Jewish learning experience and say, well, we learned in Sunday school that we're supposed to do this, and at home, we never do that. Their home life, their personal values, are what we do in the education program, in the ceremonial setting, it's a holistic identity that's consistently secular and Jewish in both Jewish and general settings. But it's because the people who found us didn't want a world where they did or thought or said some things in a Jewish setting and other things at the university, and other things when they read the newspaper or National Geographic, they wanted to feel like they could be one person everywhere. And that's what we've done. [01:18:37] Speaker B: And I think it's really important to underscore that it's sort of. I was going to say it's not okay, but the idea that if you're saying it in Hebrew, that that sort of gives it the seal of approval, even if it's not something that you believe [01:18:55] Speaker D: because [01:18:55] Speaker B: you're saying it in a language that you don't otherwise speak. No. You know, we need that consistency. And it often is that aha moment where, oh, my gosh, I don't believe anything that the Hebrew is offering me now that I have finally understood what the English is. [01:19:14] Speaker D: Do you think that that's why there's a lot of inconsistency with other religions? And I'm not asking you to criticize other religions, but the. The premise of when I initially started this podcast was bad at my religion. Like, I see a lot of people who say they believe something, but they don't live it at all. And they're not really conscious of it a lot of times sometimes they are. But if you get into conversation, then it's like there's always a rationalization as opposed to just admitting, yeah, I don't actually believe that aspect of it in a lot of other religious groups. So do you. Do you think that that's a part of the cognitive dissonance and the fracturing of individuals as being able to take agency for their own lives because they have, in a way, abdicated responsibility for the way that they live to. To this belief system? I'm Catholic, I'm Muslim, I'm Hindu, whatever it may be. And so therefore I have to follow this. Even though, like, if you really talk to them, okay, maybe I don't believe these things, but they're. They're scared of losing family or they're scared of losing their soul eternally. Like, if they choose not to believe or choose to believe what they actually believe consciously. And. And if that is something that is pervasive, is that part of the reason why there's also so much division and fighting from people who are looking to external sources like governments or corporations or AI to sort of tell them what to do, as opposed to saying, I'm a human, this is what I believe, and so I'm going to live this way. [01:21:05] Speaker B: There's a very heavy responsibility in taking agency for your own religious experiences. For me, that sort of epiphanic moment was when my grandfather died in 1986, and I realized I couldn't be Jewish by proxy, that he was the one who held the family together Jewishly. Right? He had his spot at the table to be able to lead the Passover Seder. He was the one who had the rules and of that. And even if I didn't participate or necessarily challenge him on that, it was my beloved grandfather. And so when he died, I honestly remember and use that description, I can't be Jewish by proxy. I have to start to take responsibility for my own Jewish identity. And for some people, that's very scary. It's much easier to sort of fall back on the different traditions. There's a comfort in that. There's a knowledge that, well, if it's worked for so many generations before then who am I to even challenge it? But at the end of the day, you have to look yourself in the mirror. You have to be able to answer the hard questions that your children are going to ask you, and you can't fake that. [01:22:32] Speaker E: I think the empowerment is really important. People come to us and say, can I do this? And we Almost always say yes. And we give them permission, even endorsement, for the choices they've already made, because their Judaism is theirs. We're the resource to help them. We're like. I don't know, we're like the travel agent. Tell me where you want to go, I'm going to help you get there. We're not the tour guide telling you you have to go here and here and here. That's the tour guide. We can be the travel agent. We can help you on your journey if you tell us where you want to go or what you want to experience. And in terms of the cognitive dissonance and its role in social disquiet, I think that is a really insightful statement there, because there's a growth in people who are secular, not religious, not attached to anything, but then they're seeking something else. They're looking for, as you say, someone else to tell them what to do. Whether it's a political figure or someone from pop culture or an influencer or whatever, all these people are happy to tell you what to do. And it's harder to train people and make up your own mind and decide for yourself. I'm always reminded of that wonderful scene in Monty Python's the Life of Brian where 10,000 people are following him, and he says, you don't need to follow me. You don't need to follow anyone. You can all think for yourselves. And then 10,000 people say, yes, we can all think for ourselves. [01:24:04] Speaker D: Yeah, [01:24:04] Speaker E: but we. That's what we need, are people that can actually think for themselves and do it for themselves. We try to empower people to do that. And if people had secularized in a way that they felt empowered, that they didn't feel like they were secular minus something secular, losing something without replacing it, then I think it would be a lot better for them and for us collectively. That's part of why we have a humanistic Judaism. To meet that need to fit that niche, to find positive connections with each other and our traditions and our values, to have that sense of integrity and Jewishness. It's better. I sometimes joke, we're better than nothing, which works two ways. We're better than not doing anything. It's better, you know, at least it's something. But also, we're better than being nothing, because being nothing is empty and seeking and searching and longing and lonely. But being something and living in that something gives you some sense of meaning. [01:25:04] Speaker D: But you also teach critical thinking, you said in the Sunday schools, right? So you're absolutely helping people, whether it's Just for the kids or for the kids and the adults to think critically. And I think that's something that, honestly, in most religions is not at the forefront. Because if you think critically, then you start to question. And if you start to question, then you start to get into heretical paths of sacrilegious thinking and asking about things and that, wow, that people don't have the answer to. And the worst thing in most religions that people can say is, I don't know. Like, everyone, religious leaders, I experienced this when I was growing up. Like, there has to be an answer. You. You can't say, I don't know, because then that means that you should probably be asking some questions about where this came from. Right. And you should be thinking about it. So the. The critical thinking is. I mean, that's really, really important. That I wish there was more of that. And this is actually an issue that my wife and I talked about before we got married, because I believe that it's really important to teach kids, to show them, as an example, that, look, you can have two people that believe differently about God, about the world, about what it means to be a human, that live differently, that have different ceremonies, different cultural components, but we treat each other with respect, and we both are seeking to live the best that we can and to connect with the divine in our way. I think that's really healthy for young people to see because they see, oh, I can have a disagreement with somebody but still keep the peace with that person. I don't have to hate that person just because I disagree with them. And it's okay to question because both of them are okay with questioning and having these conversations respectfully. And yet they're both, you know, looking for their own relationship with the divine or that they both have their own belief system about what it means to be human. Like, I think that's really important. [01:27:17] Speaker E: I will say my. My kids sometimes resent the fact that I taught them to think for themselves and look for evidence and try to prove their perspective. Perspective. Because so many of their friends just believe what people tell them or are part of a political or cultural, you know, movement. And. And then my kids are saying, well, but why do you think that's true? And people are like, what are you talking about? [01:27:39] Speaker D: Not popular. They're [01:27:41] Speaker E: annoyed at me that I. I train them that way. [01:27:43] Speaker B: Right, right. But [01:27:44] Speaker D: they will appreciate it later. [01:27:46] Speaker B: Yeah. And. And challenging things that can be threatening, you know, that people are. It's easier sometimes to just sort of cling to what you've been taught. What has always been done, what you perhaps say by rote. But if you start to challenge some of that, it's a threat, whether you intend it to be or not. It's often taken as a threat, you know, but definitely asking why. You know, in my Sunday school, every new student gets a little plush llama on their first day. And the reason is that the Hebrew word for why is lama. [01:28:24] Speaker D: And [01:28:25] Speaker B: I want my kids, my kids, my students to know this is the place to ask questions. And I've been doing this so long that when I get a new student, the other students will look at me and say, did you bring the llama? I'm like, yeah, trust, I brought the llama. You know, I mean, they really understand this. They have had held onto that and know why they got it and what I'm hoping to do with it. And they keep it for years and years and years, you know, so if we can. Sort of. Little kids, when you're trying to teach critical thinking, you can't say, I'm teaching you to think critically, you know? [01:29:05] Speaker D: Right, [01:29:06] Speaker B: yeah, yeah. You can make it [01:29:08] Speaker D: enjoyable and fun. [01:29:09] Speaker B: Exactly, exactly. Asking [01:29:11] Speaker D: why is natural and yet it's relished in so many different arenas. [01:29:17] Speaker B: Yes, yes. I'm thinking of my two and a half year old grandson who is at that age where everything is why. You know, you say why? And you answer, he says, why? And you answer, he says, why? And then you answer one more time, he says, how? And then you answer that, and he says, why? And finally I looked at him and I said, because of the laws of physics stopped him. He had no idea what I was talking about. But you take it sort of as far as you can with the age of the child that you're dealing with. [01:29:48] Speaker D: But more adults should do the same thing. I mean, that's one of the things that I was actually just reading the book of Elon recently, and one of his approaches to business is exactly that is asking why, if it doesn't break the laws of physics, then why can't we do it? Well, it's impossible. It'll cost too much, It'll take too long. Okay, but why? Let's break it down to the. The ingredients of a rocket, for example. What are they made of? So why can't we shed the weight by 90% and do all of these things and the cost, and eventually they figure out ways to do it. It really, it all does come down to the laws of physics. Like that sort of is, you know, material world here, the barrier. But in everything else, we should be asking why? And then eventually, how, how can we live better? Why are we living this way? Why? Why are these our values? And how can we improve? [01:30:44] Speaker B: Right. [01:30:45] Speaker E: What's funny is that so many traditional religions talk about a childlike faith, but our approach is, let's have a childlike curiosity. [01:30:53] Speaker B: Yeah. [01:30:54] Speaker D: Yes. [01:30:55] Speaker B: Yeah, [01:30:56] Speaker D: that's, that's really well said. So one, one question that I, I know this is stepping outside maybe the humanistic Judaism, but I would love to hear what you would suggest to people, sort of in this vein of thinking, people of all faiths and belief systems or that don't have. Maybe they're just completely secular, but. But not Judas or Jewish. What would be something that you would suggest people could do to take action in their own lives over the next 30 days, say, that will really have an impact? Is it something simple like asking why about whatever it is that they're doing? Or is it something like ensuring that their words align with their actions? Or something else completely? Like, what would each of you suggest? You're just in closing to anyone that's watching, listening, that they could apply to their lives. That has been really powerful in your framework, in your movement, humanistic Judaism, that they could also take and apply. [01:32:03] Speaker B: I think the examples that you give are really good ones. But I think also, as we're heading into Thanksgiving and then the holidays of Hanukkah, which is very close to Thanksgiving this year, and then Christmas, is to really understand some of the message, right, that Thanksgiving is a secular holiday. But let's not forget it's about giving thanks. Like, take a moment and sincerely acknowledge the people who are important to you, the people who are in your lives, the blessings that you have. And then as we move toward Hanukkah, maybe move away from the material and make each night, each of the eight nights of Hanukkah be a value that you're going to try and integrate more fully in your life. [01:32:50] Speaker E: And what I would do is to both look back and look forward. Looking back, if you were raised connected to Jewish culture, what were the most meaningful Jewish experiences that you had? Could have been a holiday celebration, a life cycle moment, a particular sermon or reading that really spoke to you, a food dish that stuck with you, that you just remember a visit to a place. After all, pilgrimage can be a secular experience too. So what were those most meaningful Jewish experiences? And then looking forward, where can I find, cultivate, create those experiences for myself and for other people? It could be choosing from that Jewish library of practices, like turning off the phone on a Friday night to Saturday night. It could be seeking out classes on topics that you find interesting. It could be finding Jewish artists whose work you liked one of. Why not explore more of what they do? But the point is find what speaks to you. Because it's your Judaism. You get to choose how you want to do Jewish in the ways that speak to you, find what spoke to you, and then you can find more things that will speak to you in the next 30 days. [01:34:02] Speaker D: It's really, really interesting. Thank you. Jody and Adam, where can people find you if they want to read the book, if they want to learn more, if they are Jewish, or even if they're just interested in the idea of humanistic Judaism? [01:34:19] Speaker E: Well, you can always look at our congregational websites, bethchaverim.net or kolchadash.com those are our separate congregations. The book was published by the Jewish Publication Society. Again, it's called Contemporary Humanistic Judaism. You can find that on the JPS.org website to find more about the book. And if you're looking to explore humanistic Judaism more generally, there's a society for Humanistic Judaism that has a lot of online resources, description of holidays and so on. And that would be a good place to start and maybe find a community near you. Anything else you'd add? [01:34:51] Speaker B: No, that was good. I was going to hold the book up while you were talking about it. [01:34:55] Speaker D: Is it on Amazon as well or is it just on that website? [01:34:58] Speaker E: Amazon ebooks as well as print? Yeah. [01:35:01] Speaker B: Okay, [01:35:02] Speaker D: wonderful. We'll link all of those in the description and on the listing page and everything else as well. [01:35:07] Speaker B: Great. [01:35:08] Speaker D: But I appreciate your time and the conversation was really interesting. I wish you both, I don't know if I can say the best of luck, but we make our own luck, right? So you'll have continued blessings in your lives. And yeah, thanks for sharing with me your belief system and your framework. [01:35:30] Speaker B: Thank you. [01:35:30] Speaker E: Thank you. [01:35:34] Speaker F: Like and subscribe.

Other Episodes

Episode 15

October 15, 2026 • 01:27:03
Episode Cover

Ep 15 - Bill Reel - A Good Mormon Who Questioned If He Was a Good Human

Bill Reel converted to the LDS Church at 17, became a bishop at 29, and started a podcast while still bishop to defend the...

Listen

Episode 13

October 01, 2026 • 01:27:20
Episode Cover

Ep 13 - Father Augustine Wetta - Confessions of a Terrible Monk

Father Augustine Wetta has been a Benedictine monk at Saint Louis Abbey for 30 years. He teaches high school, coaches rugby, turns the Psalms...

Listen

Episode 7

March 21, 2025 • 01:29:18
Episode Cover

Ep 7 - Rabbi Avi Kahan - Judaism and Finding God Through Debate of Law

Rabbi Avi Kahan joins us for a powerful discussion about Judaism and finding God through debate of Law, while living as a good human...

Listen